Hailed as a groundbreaking movement in software creation, open source software has become an indispensable pillar of modern software development. Often described as democratized technology, it has empowered countless individuals and organizations to collaborate and innovate. However, the community now stands at a critical juncture, and there’s some speculation that we’re seeing a decline in the open source space.
Why is Open Source so Popular in Modern Software Development?
At the heart of open source lies the power of collaboration. Unlike proprietary (closed source) software, open source invites participation from a diverse range of contributors, allowing them to work collectively to create and improve software. This inclusivity fosters shared knowledge and cooperation, leading to the creation of groundbreaking software.
In addition to collaboration, the open source development approach eliminates financial barriers and significantly enhances accessibility in software development. With open source software typically distributed under licenses that allow users to access, use, modify and distribute the software freely, this eliminates the need for costly licenses usually associated with proprietary software. This affordability allows organizations of all sizes to leverage innovative solutions without accruing high upfront costs.
Within the framework of open source software, transparency is ingrained. The accessibility of the source code makes it possible for users and contributors to scrutinize the source code, promoting trust and accountability. By promoting scrutiny and peer review, transparency ensures that flaws are quickly identified and addressed. It also empowers users to have greater control over their choices in technology.
With these benefits coupled with success stories from enormous projects like Linux, Apache and MySQL, open source positioned itself as having the potential to compete with proprietary alternatives, leading to widespread adoption across the technology industry.
More Projects are Jumping Ship
Given these numerous benefits, one might wonder: What challenges could arise with this approach? In recent years, there have been sentiments amongst contributors that the space might be losing steam. Their concerns are fueled by a few key factors that may erode or undermine the collaborative essence of the movement.
A huge factor is the commercialization of open source projects. A popular example of this phenomenon is the GitHub acquisition – GitHub, the home for open source projects for years, was acquired by the tech giant Microsoft in 2018. This news ruffled some feathers in the community, as Microsoft was seen as a proponent of proprietary software. It also raised doubts about whether GitHub would maintain autonomy over its decision-making process.
Regardless of these doubts, the community overcame the bump in the road rather quickly and continued contributing to the platform for years. However, in 2022, GitHub announced that a sub-program called Copilot, which open source developers had been working on, would emerge as a commercial product, with the profits going to GitHub itself. This development infuriated community developers, and they faced a rude awakening that any open source platform could decide to commercialize their projects without contributors sharing in the financial rewards or even gaining recognition for their work. Another open source project that has fallen victim to commercialization is OpenAI.
There have also been increasing concerns about whether open-sourcing core business models will cause more harm than good. Unlike in the past, it’s a lot easier for projects to become popular, creating a high possibility that someone else can steal the idea or offering and quickly create a commercial product based on the project.
These considerations are part of a broader discussion regarding the shifting dynamics and potential departure from the core principles within the community, causing participants to be uneasy.
The Dust Settles: Open Source Remains Strong
Despite the concerns and challenges facing the community, open source has undeniably transformed how we build and deploy software. We must approach the future of the movement with cautious optimism.
Drawing from past experiences like GitHub and OpenAI, it is clear that the community is resilient and adaptive. Contributors who do not agree with the acquisition of GitHub or the commercialization of OpenAI will take their gifts and contribute to projects whose values they agree with.
However, open source is at a crossroads and is grappling with challenges and changes that demand introspection. This introspection, hopefully, will lead to adjustments in the open source space that reaffirm its core principles and address concerns. Open source is not fizzling out, at least not yet; we can think of it as undergoing a transformative phase that will shape its future and ensure that it remains an important pillar in the software development landscape.
To hear more about cloud-native topics, join the Cloud Native Computing Foundation and the cloud-native community at KubeCon+CloudNativeCon North America 2023 – November 6-9, 2023.