As enterprises have begun to demystify the value proposition around cloud adoption, several best practices, optimization techniques and delivery models have been described in the technical community around cloud enablement and large scale adoption. While the debate between choosing private cloud vs. public cloud model has been longstanding, enterprises have been looking to mitigate the level of software disruption caused by such large transformation. A Hybrid model is thus a very appealing prospect since enterprises can still technically control the security policies and governance models, while also taking advantage of capacity bursting and other benefits of the cloud.
As with most technologies, adopting a hybrid cloud solution doesn’t buy you a free lunch either. There are several complications that are being discovered as enterprises mature into this model. One of the biggest challenges is to keep the software development lifecycle in sync across multiple target environments that are the basic backbone of a hybrid cloud model. Thus, having a robust DevOps solution is one of the key necessities for making a hybrid model work.
The Business Case for a Hybrid Cloud Model
In today’s complex business world, enterprises either by choice, or by circumstances, are choosing a hybrid model of IT solution. Enterprises are best served by implementing a “best of breed” solution, which means a combination of several domain specific SaaS (Software as a Service) and PaaS (Platform as a Service) solutions. This also eliminates any risks of a “vendor-lock in”.
So by design, a hybrid model will have a combination of the following characteristics:
- Multiple platforms within an enterprise architecture
- Both traditional as well as virtual platforms
- Domain specific SaaS/PaaS solutions, typically in a multi-vendor scenario
- Lack of standardization across cloud platforms (hypervisors, hardware types supported, so on and so forth)
Now, the challenge is to make IT delivery work seamlessly around these characteristics. This is only possible by a high degree of automation in the delivery process, operations process as well as the business planning processes. Those are the very elements a DevOps platform attempts to solve.
The Challenges of Cloud Adoption
Let’s take a quick look at some of the core existing IT capabilities built into a large enterprise.
- Security model
One of the biggest challenges towards cloud adoption is the notion of extended or revamping existing enterprise security model for cloud (and as a consequence, into DevOps solutions). How can one make sure the same security policies for data classifications and user management are applied especially on a public cloud model? Will existing audit processes suffice in a cloud model? Can existing security policies be leveraged as-is or with minor modifications and still be able to take advantage of a cloud model? These challenges will drive enterprises into a hybrid solution.
- Support and Governance models
Many enterprises have built up a history and matured best practices around IT governance and support structure (think ITIL). The cloud model in many ways disrupts those practices. One of the ways to mitigate the disruption is to adopt some form of a hybrid model so some best practices and core support capabilities can still be leveraged while taking advantage of the cloud.
One of the emerging business models for enterprises is to avail a more “managed services” model so they can focus more on their core business capabilities rather than on IT. In a managed services model, one or more service providers will be responsible for portions of the overall cloud solution while the enterprise would retain responsibilities over centralized capabilities like security. So the “hybrid” nature is not just limited to physical environments, but also around support models.
Implementing a DevOps strategy could help mitigate a lot of these issues.
Hybrid DevOps Scenario
A typical SDLC (Software Development Life cycle) DevOps looks like the following.
Figure 1 – A Typical DevOps Pipeline
The aforementioned actors in figure 1 may or may not actually be “people” since in a true DevOps world, those actors are replaced with some degree of automation. But it sets the context on what types of roles & responsibilities are expected in a typical pipeline.
Now, imagine this pipeline that is multi-folds, across several application or components. This is the real nightmare of deployment and release management issues that one has to account for since in a hybrid model. Each of these applications/components may technically reside in a totally different environment developed and managed by totally separate groups with different service level agreements.
A centralized DevOps platform, standardized across these application environment boundaries (for the most part) to provide a single pane of control over code, release and deployment management is what is required for a successful adoption of hybrid solutions.
Here is an indicative centralized architecture to solve the deployment and release management issue described above:
Figure 2 – DevOps Platform Architecture Example
The components listed in figure 2 is purely indicative and shouldn’t be misconstrued as any product marketing or messaging. The main challenge will be to standardize components to the extent possible (this is easier said than done) and stitch together a meaningful platform that works within an enterprise (based on existing tooling & processes, skills, funding etc.). Bear in mind I’m merely touching the surface in this article with regards to a DevOps platform, and limiting this to a tooling discussion. Bigger challenges do exist in the form of process and organizational transformation, which are also necessary to make a DevOps implementation successful. I’ll pen those topics in a separate article 🙂
DevOps for Hybrid cloud implementations will soon become the de facto model for process transformation in large enterprises. There is simply no other way to go about such large transformation in a purist way. There is a wide verity of use cases for a hybrid model, and most enterprise situations would fall under one or more of those categories. A robust DevOps platform is absolutely critical to making a Hybrid cloud adoption successful.
About the Author/ Sunil Joshi
Sunil is an Executive Architect with IBM. He is currently the Application Development & Innovation (AD&I) DevOps offering owner for Global Business Services. He is IBM Senior Certified and Open group certified Distinguished Architect. His specialization are in the areas of hybrid cloud solutions, platform as a service and DevOps strategy. He’s created complex hybrid solutions on cloud and DevOps for large enterprises. Sunil has authored several IBM Redbooks, blogs and also a co-author of the IBM Cloud Computing Reference Architecture (CCRA).
Sunil is passionate about international music, multi-cultural cuisine, active sports and mentoring school & college students on career path and technology.